.svg)
You've finally decided to explore marketing attribution software. You book a demo, block off 30 minutes on your calendar, and show up ready to see what the platform can do. The sales rep walks you through dashboards, clicks through features, and talks about capabilities. You nod along, ask a few surface-level questions, and end the call with a polite "we'll be in touch."
Then reality hits.
You realize you forgot to ask about the one integration that makes or breaks the deal. You didn't test whether the platform could actually handle your specific tracking challenge. You have no idea if it solves the iOS attribution nightmare that's been plaguing your Facebook campaigns. And now you're stuck either scheduling another demo or making a decision based on incomplete information.
This happens constantly. Marketers treat attribution demos like passive presentations instead of active evaluations. They walk in unprepared, miss critical questions, and leave without the insights needed to make confident platform decisions.
The cost? Delayed decisions while your attribution gaps continue bleeding budget. Choosing the wrong platform and realizing six months later it doesn't actually solve your problems. Or worse—staying stuck with your current broken tracking because you can't confidently justify the switch.
Getting real value from a marketing attribution demo requires preparation. You need to know exactly what tracking gaps you're trying to solve, which features are non-negotiable, and how to evaluate whether a platform will actually work for your specific situation.
This guide walks you through the complete preparation process. Whether you're struggling with iOS tracking limitations, juggling attribution across multiple ad platforms, or trying to prove marketing ROI to leadership, these steps will help you extract maximum value from every demo conversation. By the end, you'll have a clear framework for evaluating any attribution solution and the confidence to ask questions that reveal whether a platform truly solves your challenges.
Before you ever join a demo call, you need a crystal-clear picture of what's broken in your current attribution setup. This isn't about vague frustrations like "our tracking isn't great." You need specific, documented gaps that a new platform must solve.
Start by listing every channel and campaign type you currently can't track accurately. Can you see which Facebook ad creative drove a conversion three days later? Do you know if your LinkedIn campaigns are contributing to deals that close after multiple touchpoints? Can you track users who click an ad on mobile but convert on desktop?
Write these down. Be brutally specific.
Next, identify your most painful tracking limitations. For many marketers in 2026, iOS privacy changes remain the biggest challenge. Apple's App Tracking Transparency framework has made it nearly impossible to accurately attribute mobile conversions using standard pixel tracking. If this affects you, document exactly how: Are you missing conversion data? Seeing delayed attribution? Unable to optimize iOS campaigns effectively?
Other common gaps include cross-device tracking failures, offline conversion blind spots, and inability to connect CRM data back to original ad sources. Maybe you run Google Ads, Meta campaigns, and LinkedIn simultaneously, but you can't see how they work together in a customer's journey. Perhaps your sales team closes deals weeks after the first ad click, but your current tracking only shows last-click attribution. Understanding the digital marketing attribution problem helps you articulate these challenges more clearly during demos.
Document the business impact of each gap. This is critical. Don't just say "we can't track iOS conversions." Quantify it: "We spend $15,000 monthly on Facebook campaigns targeting iOS users but can only confirm attribution on roughly 40% of conversions. This means we're flying blind on $9,000 in monthly spend."
List the decisions you can't make confidently because of missing data. Maybe you can't determine which ad platforms deserve budget increases. Perhaps you can't prove to your CEO which marketing channels actually drive revenue. Or you're unable to optimize campaigns because you don't know which creative, audience, or message drives results.
This audit becomes your evaluation baseline. When a platform claims it solves iOS tracking challenges, you'll know exactly what that means for your $9,000 monthly blind spot. When they showcase cross-device tracking, you can immediately ask how it handles your specific scenario.
Create a simple document with three columns: Current Gap, Business Impact, and Required Solution. Fill it out completely before scheduling any demos. This transforms you from a passive observer into an informed evaluator with specific problems that need specific solutions.
Not all attribution platforms are built the same. Some excel at multi-touch attribution modeling but struggle with real-time data. Others offer seamless ad platform integrations but lack robust CRM connections. Your job is to determine which capabilities are absolutely essential versus merely nice to have.
Start with your tech stack. List every tool that must integrate with your attribution platform: your CRM (HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive), your ad platforms (Google Ads, Meta, LinkedIn, TikTok), your website platform, your analytics tools, and any marketing automation software. If a platform can't connect to your CRM, it's probably a deal-breaker—you won't be able to track the full customer journey from ad click to closed deal.
Determine your accuracy requirements. Some businesses can tolerate 80% attribution accuracy. Others—particularly those in highly regulated industries or with tight margins—need near-perfect tracking. Be honest about your standards. If you're making million-dollar budget decisions based on attribution data, you need a platform with server-side tracking capabilities that bypass browser limitations and cookie restrictions.
Consider your attribution model needs. Do you need to compare first-click, last-click, linear, time-decay, and position-based models? Or will a single model suffice? Many marketers discover that different stakeholders prefer different models—your CEO wants to see first-touch attribution to understand top-of-funnel performance, while your performance marketing team needs last-click data for optimization. Reviewing the types of marketing attribution models before your demo helps you ask informed questions about model flexibility.
Think about reporting requirements. Who needs to see this data? If it's just you, a complex dashboard might be fine. But if you're presenting to executives, you need clean, digestible reports that non-marketers can understand. If your team includes multiple campaign managers, you'll need role-based access and customizable views.
Evaluate your optimization workflow. The best attribution platforms don't just show you what happened—they help you make better decisions. Does the platform need AI-powered recommendations? Should it automatically sync conversion data back to your ad platforms to improve their algorithms? Can it suggest budget reallocation based on actual revenue attribution?
Create two lists: "Must Have" and "Nice to Have." Be ruthless about the distinction. A must-have feature is something without which the platform is useless to you. A nice-to-have feature would improve your experience but isn't a deal-breaker. This clarity prevents you from getting distracted by impressive features that don't actually solve your core problems.
Generic questions get generic answers. "Can you track conversions?" will get you a confident "Yes" from every platform. Strategic questions reveal the truth about whether a platform actually solves your specific challenges.
Ask about their data accuracy methodology. Don't accept vague answers. Specifically ask: "How do you handle iOS tracking limitations?" and "What percentage of conversions do you typically capture compared to platform-native reporting?" A quality platform will explain their server-side tracking approach, first-party data collection methods, and how they validate accuracy.
Dig into attribution model flexibility. Ask: "Can I compare multiple attribution models side-by-side for the same time period?" and "How customizable are your models—can I create custom rules for specific campaign types?" This reveals whether you're locked into their predetermined models or can adapt the platform to your business logic. Understanding what is predetermined in marketing attribution models helps you evaluate vendor responses more critically.
Question the implementation process directly. Ask: "What's your typical implementation timeline from contract signing to full data accuracy?" and "What resources do we need on our end—developer time, IT support, dedicated project manager?" Some platforms promise quick setup but require weeks of developer work. Others offer guided implementation but need significant internal coordination.
Probe their integration capabilities with specifics. Don't just ask if they integrate with Salesforce. Ask: "How does the integration work—does it require custom fields, can it handle our specific lead stages, and how often does data sync?" Request the same detail for every critical integration in your tech stack.
Inquire about data enrichment and conversion sync. Ask: "How do you feed conversion data back to ad platforms?" and "Can you send custom conversion events with specific parameters to improve platform algorithms?" This reveals whether the platform just reports on attribution or actively improves your ad performance by giving platforms better optimization signals.
Question their AI capabilities if they claim to offer recommendations. Ask: "What specific recommendations does your AI provide?" and "How does it determine which campaigns to scale versus pause?" Vague AI claims are common—you want concrete examples of actionable insights the system generates. Learning how machine learning can be used in marketing attribution prepares you to evaluate these claims effectively.
Request specifics on data retention and historical analysis. Ask: "How far back can I analyze data?" and "If I implement today, can I import historical conversion data to establish baselines?" Some platforms only track forward from implementation, which means you lose valuable historical context.
These questions force vendors to move beyond rehearsed feature pitches and demonstrate real platform capabilities. Write them down before your demo. Don't let the conversation flow distract you from getting answers to each one.
Standard demo scripts showcase the platform's best features. Customized demos show you whether it solves your actual problems. The difference is massive.
Before the demo, send the vendor your specific scenarios. Share the attribution gaps you documented in Step 1. Explain your tech stack, your campaign structure, and your biggest tracking challenges. Give them enough detail to prepare a relevant presentation.
For example: "We run Facebook, Google, and LinkedIn campaigns simultaneously. Our typical customer journey includes 3-5 touchpoints over 2-3 weeks before converting. We need to see how your platform would attribute a conversion that started with a LinkedIn ad view, included two Facebook ad clicks, and converted after a Google search. Can you walk through exactly how that would appear in your reporting?" This scenario tests their multi-touch marketing attribution software capabilities directly.
Request to see the specific reports you'd use daily. Generic dashboards look impressive but might not surface the insights you actually need. Ask to see: "Can you show me the exact report I'd check each morning to decide where to allocate budget today?" or "What would the weekly executive summary look like that I'd send to leadership?"
Ask them to demonstrate your exact ad platform combination. If you run campaigns on Meta, Google, TikTok, and Pinterest, see all four integrations in action. Don't accept "it works the same way" for platforms they don't show. Each integration has nuances, and you need to verify they all function as promised.
Request a walkthrough of how AI recommendations would apply to your campaign types. If they claim AI-powered insights, ask: "Based on a scenario where my Facebook campaigns are driving awareness but Google is closing deals, what specific recommendation would your AI make?" This tests whether their AI provides generic advice or contextual insights.
See the platform handle your data volume. If you process 10,000 conversions monthly across 50 campaigns, make sure the demo reflects that scale. Platforms that work beautifully with small data sets sometimes struggle with enterprise-level volume.
Ask to see the mobile experience if your team needs on-the-go access. Some platforms offer robust desktop dashboards but clunky mobile interfaces. If you or your team check performance from phones, verify the mobile experience meets your needs.
The goal is to eliminate surprises. After a truly customized demo, you should know exactly what using this platform would look like in your daily workflow. No guessing. No assumptions. Just clear evidence of whether it solves your specific challenges.
During the demo, you're not just watching a presentation. You're actively scoring the platform against your predetermined criteria. This requires discipline—it's easy to get swept up in impressive features that don't actually matter to your use case.
Open the must-have features list you created in Step 2. As the vendor demonstrates each capability, mark whether it fully meets your requirement, partially meets it, or doesn't address it at all. Be honest. "Partially meets" means there's a workaround or limitation—note exactly what it is.
Cross-reference the demo against your documented attribution gaps from Step 1. Did they directly address your iOS tracking challenge? Did they show how the platform handles your cross-device scenario? If a gap wasn't addressed, ask about it immediately. Don't assume they'll cover it later.
Assess the user experience realistically. Could your team actually use this daily? Some platforms offer incredibly powerful capabilities but require extensive training. Others are intuitive but lack depth. Consider your team's technical skill level and bandwidth for learning new tools.
Evaluate the reporting clarity. Pull up the reports they showed and ask yourself: "Could I present this to my CEO and have them understand it in 30 seconds?" Attribution data is only valuable if stakeholders can interpret it quickly. Complex visualizations that require explanation won't serve you well in executive meetings. Understanding the power of marketing attribution reports helps you assess whether a platform's reporting meets executive communication standards.
Verify integration claims against your specific tools. They might integrate with Salesforce generally, but does it work with your Salesforce configuration? Do they support the specific CRM fields you use for lead scoring? Can they handle your custom conversion events?
Note any red flags or concerns immediately. Did the platform lag when loading reports? Did the vendor dodge a specific question? Was there a feature they couldn't demonstrate live? These aren't necessarily deal-breakers, but they warrant follow-up.
Pay attention to what they didn't show. If they focused heavily on certain features but glossed over others, there's usually a reason. Ask to see the capabilities they skipped. Sometimes platforms showcase their strengths while minimizing weaknesses.
Score the platform on a simple scale for each must-have feature: Exceeds Expectations, Meets Expectations, Below Expectations, or Does Not Address. This creates a quantifiable evaluation you can compare across multiple platform demos. Gut feelings matter, but documented scores prevent you from making emotional decisions based on whoever gave the most polished presentation.
The demo is over. Now the real evaluation begins. Most marketers make platform decisions based on recency bias—whoever presented last or most recently often wins. A structured follow-up process ensures you choose based on actual fit, not presentation polish.
Request trial access or a proof-of-concept if available. Nothing reveals platform limitations like actually using it with your real data. Even a limited trial with sample campaigns provides insights no demo can match. You'll discover interface quirks, reporting gaps, and workflow friction that weren't apparent during the presentation.
If you're evaluating multiple platforms, create a comparison spreadsheet. List your must-have features down the left column and each platform across the top. Fill in how each platform scored on every criterion. This side-by-side comparison makes the right choice obvious—you're looking for the platform that checks the most must-have boxes, not the one with the most total features. Resources on comparing marketing attribution software features can help structure your evaluation framework.
Involve the people who will actually use the platform daily. Your campaign managers, analysts, and reporting team should evaluate the interface and workflow. A platform you love might frustrate your team if they're the ones using it eight hours a day. Schedule a 15-minute walkthrough with key users and get their honest feedback.
Calculate potential ROI based on your documented attribution gaps. If you're currently wasting $9,000 monthly on blind iOS spend, and a platform costs $2,000 monthly but recovers that visibility, the ROI is clear. Quantify the value of solving each gap you identified in Step 1. This transforms the platform cost from an expense into an investment with measurable return. Understanding how marketing attribution software enables revenue attribution helps you build a compelling business case for leadership.
Ask for customer references in your industry or with similar use cases. Talk to marketers who faced the same attribution challenges you're trying to solve. Ask them: "What surprised you after implementation?" and "What do you wish you'd known before choosing this platform?" Their answers reveal real-world performance beyond the demo script.
Request detailed implementation documentation. Before signing anything, understand exactly what the setup process involves. How much developer time is required? What data needs to be prepared? How long until you're seeing accurate attribution? A platform that takes three months to implement might not be worth it if you need answers in weeks.
Set a decision deadline. Without a timeline, platform evaluations drag on indefinitely while your attribution gaps continue costing you. Give yourself a specific date by which you'll make a choice. This creates urgency and prevents analysis paralysis.
Walking into a marketing attribution demo prepared transforms the experience from a passive presentation into an active evaluation that leads to confident platform decisions. The difference between marketers who choose the right attribution solution and those who end up stuck with the wrong one often comes down to preparation.
Use this framework before your next demo: First, audit your current tracking gaps and document the specific business impact of each limitation. Second, define your must-have features and deal-breakers based on your tech stack and accuracy requirements. Third, prepare strategic questions that reveal real platform capabilities beyond marketing claims. Fourth, request a customized demo using your actual use cases and campaign scenarios. Fifth, actively score the platform against your predetermined criteria during the presentation. Finally, follow up with structured evaluation including trials, team feedback, and ROI calculations.
The right attribution platform should clearly address your specific challenges. Whether that's capturing every touchpoint across channels despite iOS limitations, understanding which sources actually drive revenue beyond last-click attribution, getting AI-powered recommendations for campaign optimization, or feeding enriched conversion data back to your ad platforms to improve their targeting algorithms.
You're not just buying software. You're investing in the ability to make confident marketing decisions backed by accurate data. The platform that solves your documented gaps, integrates seamlessly with your existing tools, and provides insights your team can actually use—that's the one worth your investment.
Ready to elevate your marketing game with precision and confidence? Discover how Cometly's AI-driven recommendations can transform your ad strategy—Get your free demo today and start capturing every touchpoint to maximize your conversions.
Learn how Cometly can help you pinpoint channels driving revenue.
.svg)
Network with the top performance marketers in the industry
